Handle non-EPR devices not encoding PPS correctly (#1911)

Handle non EPR devices not encoding PPS correctly

By not trusting them at all.
This commit is contained in:
Ben V. Brown
2024-05-24 18:21:42 +10:00
committed by GitHub
parent f11290891e
commit 88d7a8e154
2 changed files with 76 additions and 53 deletions

View File

@@ -167,56 +167,67 @@ bool parseCapabilitiesArray(const uint8_t numCaps, uint8_t *bestIndex, uint16_t
} }
} }
} }
} else if ((lastCapabilities[i] & PD_PDO_TYPE) == PD_PDO_TYPE_AUGMENTED && (((lastCapabilities[i] & PD_APDO_TYPE) == PD_APDO_TYPE_PPS)) && getSettingValue(SettingsOptions::PDVpdo)) { } else if ((lastCapabilities[i] & PD_PDO_TYPE) == PD_PDO_TYPE_AUGMENTED && getSettingValue(SettingsOptions::PDVpdo)) {
// If this is a PPS slot, calculate the max voltage in the PPS range that can we be used and maintain bool sourceIsEPRCapable = lastCapabilities[0] & PD_PDO_SRC_FIXED_EPR_CAPABLE;
uint16_t max_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCapabilities[i])); bool isPPS = false;
// uint16_t min_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MIN_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCapabilities[i])); bool isAVS = false;
uint16_t max_current = PD_PAI2CA(PD_APDO_PPS_CURRENT_GET(lastCapabilities[i])); // max current in 10mA units if (sourceIsEPRCapable) {
// Using the current and tip resistance, calculate the ideal max voltage isPPS = (lastCapabilities[i] & PD_APDO_TYPE) == PD_APDO_TYPE_PPS;
// if this is range, then we will work with this voltage isAVS = (lastCapabilities[i] & PD_APDO_TYPE) == PD_APDO_TYPE_AVS;
// if this is not in range; then max_voltage can be safely selected } else {
int ideal_voltage_mv = (tipResistance * max_current); isPPS = true; // Assume PPS if no EPR support
if (ideal_voltage_mv > max_voltage) {
ideal_voltage_mv = max_voltage; // constrain to what this PDO offers
} }
if (ideal_voltage_mv > 20000) { if (isPPS) {
ideal_voltage_mv = 20000; // Limit to 20V as some advertise 21 but are not stable at 21 // If this is a PPS slot, calculate the max voltage in the PPS range that can we be used and maintain
uint16_t max_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCapabilities[i]));
// uint16_t min_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MIN_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCapabilities[i]));
uint16_t max_current = PD_PAI2CA(PD_APDO_PPS_CURRENT_GET(lastCapabilities[i])); // max current in 10mA units
// Using the current and tip resistance, calculate the ideal max voltage
// if this is range, then we will work with this voltage
// if this is not in range; then max_voltage can be safely selected
int ideal_voltage_mv = (tipResistance * max_current);
if (ideal_voltage_mv > max_voltage) {
ideal_voltage_mv = max_voltage; // constrain to what this PDO offers
}
if (ideal_voltage_mv > 20000) {
ideal_voltage_mv = 20000; // Limit to 20V as some advertise 21 but are not stable at 21
}
if (ideal_voltage_mv > (USB_PD_VMAX * 1000)) {
ideal_voltage_mv = (USB_PD_VMAX * 1000); // constrain to model max voltage safe to select
}
if (ideal_voltage_mv > *bestVoltage) {
*bestIndex = i;
*bestVoltage = ideal_voltage_mv;
*bestCurrent = max_current;
*bestIsPPS = true;
*bestIsAVS = false;
}
} }
if (ideal_voltage_mv > (USB_PD_VMAX * 1000)) {
ideal_voltage_mv = (USB_PD_VMAX * 1000); // constrain to model max voltage safe to select
}
if (ideal_voltage_mv > *bestVoltage) {
*bestIndex = i;
*bestVoltage = ideal_voltage_mv;
*bestCurrent = max_current;
*bestIsPPS = true;
*bestIsAVS = false;
}
}
#ifdef POW_EPR #ifdef POW_EPR
else if ((lastCapabilities[i] & PD_PDO_TYPE) == PD_PDO_TYPE_AUGMENTED && (((lastCapabilities[i] & PD_APDO_TYPE) == PD_APDO_TYPE_AVS)) && getSettingValue(SettingsOptions::PDVpdo)) { else if (isAVS) {
uint16_t max_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_AVS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCapabilities[i])); uint16_t max_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_AVS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCapabilities[i]));
uint8_t max_wattage = PD_APDO_AVS_MAX_POWER_GET(lastCapabilities[i]); uint8_t max_wattage = PD_APDO_AVS_MAX_POWER_GET(lastCapabilities[i]);
// W = v^2/tip_resistance => Wattage*tip_resistance == Max_voltage^2 // W = v^2/tip_resistance => Wattage*tip_resistance == Max_voltage^2
auto ideal_max_voltage = sqrtI((max_wattage * tipResistance) / 10) * 1000; auto ideal_max_voltage = sqrtI((max_wattage * tipResistance) / 10) * 1000;
if (ideal_max_voltage > (USB_PD_VMAX * 1000)) { if (ideal_max_voltage > (USB_PD_VMAX * 1000)) {
ideal_max_voltage = (USB_PD_VMAX * 1000); // constrain to model max voltage safe to select ideal_max_voltage = (USB_PD_VMAX * 1000); // constrain to model max voltage safe to select
} }
if (ideal_max_voltage > (max_voltage)) { if (ideal_max_voltage > (max_voltage)) {
ideal_max_voltage = (max_voltage); // constrain to model max voltage safe to select ideal_max_voltage = (max_voltage); // constrain to model max voltage safe to select
} }
auto operating_current = (ideal_max_voltage / tipResistance); // Current in centiamps auto operating_current = (ideal_max_voltage / tipResistance); // Current in centiamps
if (ideal_max_voltage > *bestVoltage) { if (ideal_max_voltage > *bestVoltage) {
*bestIndex = i; *bestIndex = i;
*bestVoltage = ideal_max_voltage; *bestVoltage = ideal_max_voltage;
*bestCurrent = operating_current; *bestCurrent = operating_current;
*bestIsAVS = true; *bestIsAVS = true;
*bestIsPPS = false; *bestIsPPS = false;
}
} }
}
#endif #endif
}
} }
// Now that the best index is known, set the current values // Now that the best index is known, set the current values
return *bestIndex != 0xFF; // have we selected one return *bestIndex != 0xFF; // have we selected one

View File

@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
#include "OperatingModes.h" #include "OperatingModes.h"
#ifdef POW_PD #ifdef POW_PD
#include "pd.h"
#ifdef HAS_POWER_DEBUG_MENU #ifdef HAS_POWER_DEBUG_MENU
OperatingMode showPDDebug(const ButtonState buttons, guiContext *cxt) { OperatingMode showPDDebug(const ButtonState buttons, guiContext *cxt) {
// Print out the USB-PD state // Print out the USB-PD state
@@ -27,7 +28,8 @@ OperatingMode showPDDebug(const ButtonState buttons, guiContext *cxt) {
} }
} else { } else {
// Print out the Proposed power options one by one // Print out the Proposed power options one by one
auto lastCaps = USBPowerDelivery::getLastSeenCapabilities(); auto lastCaps = USBPowerDelivery::getLastSeenCapabilities();
bool sourceIsEPRCapable = lastCaps[0] & PD_PDO_SRC_FIXED_EPR_CAPABLE;
if (((*screen) - 1) < 11) { if (((*screen) - 1) < 11) {
int voltage_mv = 0; int voltage_mv = 0;
int min_voltage = 0; int min_voltage = 0;
@@ -37,15 +39,25 @@ OperatingMode showPDDebug(const ButtonState buttons, guiContext *cxt) {
if ((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_PDO_TYPE) == PD_PDO_TYPE_FIXED) { if ((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_PDO_TYPE) == PD_PDO_TYPE_FIXED) {
voltage_mv = PD_PDV2MV(PD_PDO_SRC_FIXED_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); // voltage in mV units voltage_mv = PD_PDV2MV(PD_PDO_SRC_FIXED_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); // voltage in mV units
current_a_x100 = PD_PDO_SRC_FIXED_CURRENT_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]); // current in 10mA units current_a_x100 = PD_PDO_SRC_FIXED_CURRENT_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]); // current in 10mA units
} else if (((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_PDO_TYPE) == PD_PDO_TYPE_AUGMENTED) && ((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_APDO_TYPE) == PD_APDO_TYPE_AVS)) { } else if ((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_PDO_TYPE) == PD_PDO_TYPE_AUGMENTED) {
voltage_mv = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_AVS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); if (sourceIsEPRCapable) {
min_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MIN_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); if ((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_APDO_TYPE) == PD_APDO_TYPE_AVS) {
// Last value is wattage voltage_mv = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_AVS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]));
wattage = PD_APDO_AVS_MAX_POWER_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]); min_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MIN_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]));
} else if (((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_PDO_TYPE) == PD_PDO_TYPE_AUGMENTED) && ((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_APDO_TYPE) == PD_APDO_TYPE_PPS)) { // Last value is wattage
voltage_mv = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); wattage = PD_APDO_AVS_MAX_POWER_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]);
min_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MIN_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); } else if (((lastCaps[(*screen) - 1] & PD_APDO_TYPE) == PD_APDO_TYPE_PPS)) {
current_a_x100 = PD_PAI2CA(PD_APDO_PPS_CURRENT_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); // max current in 10mA units voltage_mv = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]));
min_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MIN_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]));
current_a_x100 = PD_PAI2CA(PD_APDO_PPS_CURRENT_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); // max current in 10mA units
}
} else {
// Doesn't have EPR support. So treat as PPS
// https://github.com/Ralim/IronOS/issues/1906
voltage_mv = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MAX_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]));
min_voltage = PD_PAV2MV(PD_APDO_PPS_MIN_VOLTAGE_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1]));
current_a_x100 = PD_PAI2CA(PD_APDO_PPS_CURRENT_GET(lastCaps[(*screen) - 1])); // max current in 10mA units
}
} }
// Skip not used entries // Skip not used entries
if (voltage_mv == 0) { if (voltage_mv == 0) {